Saturday 3 January 2015

Is Islam political-religious threat!



One of my uncles had a rare gift of spinning stories out of hypothesis, controversies and predictions. His purpose was to acquaint others with world affairs and history in a light manner. Islam was always a favourite topic and whether it was politics, conspiracies or Islamism he tried to reason out the complications as best as he could do it. Once in a matter-of-fact way he mentioned to me the comments Francis Mitterand made in reference to Muslims, where he stated that the rising tide of Islam in Europe can lead to a situation making it possible for a Muslim to be elected as the French president.

Thirty years ago this seemed a strange prediction. Far from being interested in politics that could lead to crisis between Islam and West I did not take these comments seriously. But nowadays it is not easy to overlook that identification with Islam is creating conflicts. We hear of Sharia patrols in UK, anti-Islam protest march in Germany, riots in Europe, blasphemy charges raised against those who draw cartoons and drawings becoming a frequent occurrence. It is usually dismissed that these incidences are engineered by those who want to stir trouble, brand Islam as intolerant and not compatible with the times.  

Whether my uncle said these comments in response to the argument that Islam is a violent religion spread by the use of sword in medieval times I am not sure. He died soon after 9/11 and never got the chance to see the turn of tide where the blind conviction in Quran and Haadith as the perfect embodiment of law, led to the birth of Islamic State ISIS who believe in modern-day slavery, beheading and amputations. Islam is seen as a force which has foes and believers alike. Whether as an outcome of economic meltdown, lack of trust in politicians or suffering from affluenza (‘a painful, contagious, socially transmitted condition of overload, debt, anxiety and waste resulting from the dogged pursuit of more’), all over the world the young people are turning to religion. Islam as a role model is growing, for it offers the closest example to ‘living religion’ whose adherents really believe in God and his Law. The influence of Islam is everywhere.
Hijab-clad woman greets me at the chemist, I read the word ‘halal’ emblazoned on the sign boards of many restaurants across Birmingham, I walk pass prayer-rooms in airports and hospitals and I get to listen to Adhan ‘call for prayers’ on radio.

However I fail to adhere to becoming a follower without understanding why those who believe in tolerance are ready to harass others for drawing images of the Prophet! Those who believe in Islam have a desire to see it dominate by the increase in numbers of converts. Though it is deemed that all are equal before God, yet it is constantly preached that Christians, Jews, Atheists, Hindus are less equals because they don’t follow Islam. In this day and age women are told that segregation is a way of giving them respect. Forced marriages, honour killings and violence to compel girls to cover their heads and faces is sometimes not even considered violation of basic rights for women.

 Much of the sovereignty of the European states is being transferred to the European Union: radical Muslims may wonder why they should come to terms with the national governments rather than the supranational authority in Brussels. Politics may accelerate Islamization. Muslim vote will be crucial in many elections across Europe; to win it may mean having to woo it, notably by allowing for further consolidation of Islam in society. Along these lines, one might also wonder whether Jacques Chirac’s pronouncements in late 1996 strongly favouring an independent Palestinian state and the lifting of the embargo against Iraq were not intended to garner the Muslim vote in France. One may also question why the British government never tried to intervene to stop genocide by Assad government in Syria.


Anyone who believes in the existence of specific political-religious threat will probably think of Islam first. The current debate about immigration is much more than only about ethnicity and language----it is about religion too. We must consider whether the rise of Islam means number of mosques should double, halal food distribution must boost, polygamy is to be tolerated and the Sharia police to be allowed to operate in Muslim neighbourhoods. Or Islam ought to adapt to the British values, with its emphasis on individual freedom and secularism, rather than the reverse.  

1 comment:

  1. "However I fail to adhere to becoming a follower without understanding why those who believe in tolerance are ready to harass others for drawing images of the Prophet!"

    Drawing pictures of living things is forbidden in Islam.

    "Narrated 'Aisha: Allah's Apostle ﷺ returned from a journey when I had placed a curtain of mine having pictures over (the door of) a chamber of mine. When Allah's Apostle ﷺ saw it, he ﷺ tore it and said, "The people who will receive the severest punishment on the Day of Resurrection will be those who try to make the like of Allah's creations." So we turned it (i.e., the curtain) into one or two cushions." (BUKHARI - Book of Dress)

    The Messenger ﷺ told Aisha that those who make images will be severely punished because imitating God's creation is forbidden. Further, scholars have deemed the attempt to portray the Messenger ﷺ as degrading to his status. Any insult to the Messenger ﷺ is blasphemy and punishable by death according to the shari'ah.

    "Though it is deemed that all are equal before God, yet it is constantly preached that Christians, Jews, Atheists, Hindus are less equals because they don’t follow Islam."

    Islam does not recognize that all people are equal. God states that the best of people are those who are most righteous, implying that those who are less righteous are valued correspondingly as less. The disbelievers are not equal to the believers according to God, just as the blind is not the same as those who see. Their unequal status is reflective of their destinations in the Hereafter. The disbeliever is destined for the Fire while the believer, God willing, shall enter Paradise.

    "In this day and age women are told that segregation is a way of giving them respect."

    Whatever the wisdom behind segregation it is mandatory in some instances for men and women to be separate, especially those who are not of the same family.

    "Forced marriages, honour killings..."

    No woman can be forced into a marriage. If she does not consent to the marriage, then her marriage is invalid. Similarly, there is no provision in Islam for 'honor killings'. A Muslim's blood is sacrosanct except as stated by law: in the instance of murder, adultery, apostasy, etc.

    "... violence to compel girls to cover their heads and faces is sometimes not even considered violation of basic rights for women."

    Implementation of the shari'ah is mandatory. Part of that law is that women properly veil themselves (which includes their bodies, heads and faces). If someone breaks that law, then they are punished. Islam does not generally recognize fines or imprisonment as punishment, but lashings or floggings are prescribed. This is not a violation of anyone's rights as Islam is a complete system and one's rights are defined by Islam.

    "... radical Muslims may wonder why they should come to terms with the national governments rather than the supranational authority in Brussels."

    Muslims do not 'come to terms' with any system other than Islam. To recognize a law other than God's law is an act of disbelief. In Islam, the role of legislator belongs to God alone. The Messenger ﷺ stated that the people who obey others and disobey God in those matters which God has permitted or prohibited are disbelievers because they have taken others as lords besides God.

    "We must consider ... rather than the reverse."

    Islam does not adapt to any system as it is a complete way of life, designed and conveyed by God through Muhammad ﷺ. God states that no system is acceptable unto Him except Islam and if any attempt to please God, obey Him or come near to Him through anything other than Islam, then those acts or attempts will be rejected. British values contradict Islam. There can be no reconciliation between Islam and any other system.

    ReplyDelete